Hangry birds

Interactions between birds may look chaotic, but there’s a method to the madness. Play to find out which ones dominate at your feeder and why.

Published March 11, 2024

From the bullies to the conflict averse, a hierarchy of social dominance helps birds assess their prospects and determines which of them gets the best food and perch positions.

The downy woodpecker—geographically widespread and a feeder regular—can often be spotted in encounters with other North American bird species and provides a good point of comparison. See how your avian intuition measures up as the downy faces off with the following five birds:

Which bird will win?

(1 of 5)

VS

Higher body weight is a frequent indicator of dominance. The blue jay is large, heavy, loud, typically aggressive, and capable of mimicking hawk calls—all factors that can displace the downy.

You’d think its pecking might help, but the downy is displaced by the jay and its higher body weight—a frequent indicator of dominance. The blue jay is also loud and typically aggressive.

Which bird will win?

(2 of 5)

VS

The chickadee avoids confrontation and cannot outcompete the downy and most other species because of its small size and light weight.

The chickadee doesn’t fare well at feeders. It avoids confrontation and cannot outcompete the downy and most other species because of its small size and light weight.

Which bird will win?

(3 of 5)

VS

The cardinal and the downy generally avoid each other. But when they fight, the heavier cardinal is defeated thanks to the woodpecker’s tree-hammering skills.

This is a close one. The cardinal and the downy generally avoid each other. But the heavier cardinal is defeated thanks to the woodpecker’s tree-hammering skills.

Which bird will win?

(4 of 5)

VS

These two woodpeckers have a similar diet and habitat, which fuels frequent conflicts. The red-bellied is bigger than the downy and often displaces it.

These two woodpeckers often go beak-to-beak. Both have a similar diet and habitat, which fuels frequent conflicts, but the red-bellied is bigger than the downy.

Which bird will win?

(5 of 5)

VS

They have similar weights and don’t interact much, but the woodpecker tends to win. Why? We’re not sure. The house sparrow is invasive to North America, and scientists think its status in the social hierarchy may still be shifting.

This is a tricky one. The downy and house sparrow have similar weights, but the woodpecker tends to win. The house sparrow is invasive to North America, and scientists think its status in the social hierarchy may still be shifting.

Scroll to continue

HOW DO THESE BIRDS MEASURE UP?

There are several factors that influence the social interactions between birds. Some of the key ones are dominance, often indicated by body weight, and whether the birds eat similar foods—birds with similar diets interact more frequently.

See below how 19 birds compare to the downy woodpecker in terms of body weight, and what happens when they interact.

Confronts

than the downy woodpecker

the

downy woodpecker

Heavier

Avoids

Lighter

Downy woodpecker

LOSERS

WINNERS

Common grackle

Bushtit

Titmouse

Blue jay

Pine siskin

Northern flicker

House finch

Black-

capped chickadee

Northern mockingbird

American goldfinch

European starling

Northern cardinal

Dark-eyed junco

Red-bellied woodpecker

Red-

breasted nuthatch

Hairy woodpecker

House sparrow

Carolina wren

White-

breasted nuthatch

than the downy woodpecker

Heavier

Lighter

Confronts

the

downy woodpecker

Avoids

WINNERS

Common grackle

Blue jay

Northern flicker

Northern mockingbird

European starling

Red-bellied woodpecker

Hairy woodpecker

LOSERS

Bushtit

Titmouse

Pine siskin

House finch

Black-

capped chickadee

American goldfinch

Northern cardinal

Dark-eyed junco

Red-

breasted nuthatch

House sparrow

Carolina wren

White-

breasted nuthatch

Data collected by about 9,500 citizen scientists with Project FeederWatch between 2016 and 2022.

Source: Eliot Miller, Cornell Lab of Ornithology and American Bird Conservancy

This story appears in the March 2024 issue of National Geographic magazine.

Graphics editor: Diana Marques

Development: Ben Scott, Ryan Morris

Text editor: Eve Conant

Design: Andrea Nasca

Research: Kelsey Nowakowski

Copy editor: Jennifer Vilaga